Every philosophy eventually has to answer the same awkward question: why does it hurt? The Dharmic traditions did not treat suffering as a theological embarrassment to be explained away. They treated it as the starting point. Indian philosophy, almost alone among the world's great traditions, often opens its books with pain.
Three Kinds of Suffering
Īśvarakṛṣṇa's Sāṃkhyakārikā begins:
दुःखत्रयाभिघाताज्जिज्ञासा तदपघातके हेतौ ।
duḥkhatrayābhighātāj jijñāsā tadapaghātake hetau
"From the torment of the threefold suffering arises the desire to know the means of removing it." (Sāṃkhyakārikā 1)
The commentators name the three:
- Ādhyātmika: suffering from within: illness of body and mind;
- Ādhibhautika: suffering from other beings: people, animals, injury;
- Ādhidaivika: suffering from forces beyond control: weather, earthquake, fate.
It is a remarkably modern taxonomy: personal, social and environmental. Philosophy exists, for Sāṃkhya, because ordinary remedies (medicine, wealth, ritual) relieve these only temporarily.
The Buddha's Diagnosis
The Buddha's first sermon, the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta (Saṃyutta Nikāya 56.11), sets out the Four Noble Truths in the form of a medical diagnosis: the illness (dukkha), its cause (taṇhā, craving), the possibility of cure (nirodha), and the treatment (the Eightfold Path).
Dukkha is broader than pain. It includes the unsatisfactoriness of even pleasant things, because they change. A perfect holiday is still a holiday that ends. The tradition names three layers: plain pain (dukkha-dukkha), the pain of change (vipariṇāma-dukkha), and the subtle unease of conditioned existence itself (saṅkhāra-dukkha).
Ignorance as the Root
The Yoga tradition locates the cause in the kleśas, the afflictions, and their root avidyā, ignorance: "taking the impermanent, impure, painful and non-self to be permanent, pure, pleasant and self" (Yoga Sūtra 2.5). The sūtra that follows is famous for its optimism: "Suffering that has not yet come is to be avoided" (heyaṃ duḥkham anāgatam, 2.16). Not all suffering can be prevented, but future suffering can.
Karma: Explanation, Not Blame
The doctrine of karma explains suffering as the ripening of past action. Misused, it becomes cruelty: "they must have deserved it." The tradition itself resists this. The Mahābhārata repeatedly shows good people suffering undeservedly, and Yudhiṣṭhira's question to Dharma at the lake (Vana Parva, Yakṣa-praśna) treats the world's strangeness with humility. The Gītā never tells Arjuna to ignore others' pain. Karma is a reason to act well, not a licence to judge.
Dharmic Responses
Different schools prescribe different remedies:
- Vedānta: suffering belongs to the body-mind, not the Self; knowledge of the Self brings freedom.
- Bhakti: suffering can be offered to God and transformed by love. Kuntī, in the Bhāgavata Purāṇa (1.8.25), astonishingly asks for calamities, because they keep her mindful of Kṛṣṇa.
- Buddhism: see craving clearly and release it.
- Jainism: purify karma through non-violence and austerity.
- Sikhism: accept hukam, the divine order, while serving others.
Compassion, Not Detachment Alone
A common caricature says Indian thought counsels indifference to suffering. The texts disagree. The Buddhist ideal of karuṇā (compassion), the bodhisattva vow to save all beings, the Sikh tradition of seva and langar, and the Gītā's praise of one "who delights in the welfare of all beings" (sarvabhūtahite ratāḥ, 5.25; 12.4) all make the relief of suffering a spiritual duty.
Modern Resonances
Psychological approaches such as Acceptance and Commitment Therapy and Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy explicitly draw on Buddhist analysis of suffering, distinguishing pain from the added suffering of resisting it. Jon Kabat-Zinn's Full Catastrophe Living (1990) brought this to medicine. The evidence for mindfulness in preventing depressive relapse is reasonably strong (Kuyken et al., 2016), though not a cure-all.
For Every Reader
- For children: when you fall over, the hurt is one thing; being cross about it is another. Which lasts longer?
- For adults: name one current difficulty. Is it ādhyātmika, ādhibhautika or ādhidaivika? Each needs a different response.
- For organisations: reduce avoidable suffering ("heyaṃ duḥkham anāgatam"), and support people through what cannot be avoided.
References
- Īśvarakṛṣṇa, Sāṃkhyakārikā, trans. Gerald J. Larson, Classical Sāṃkhya (Motilal Banarsidass, 1969).
- Bhikkhu Bodhi (trans.), The Connected Discourses of the Buddha (Wisdom, 2000), SN 56.11.
- Edwin F. Bryant, The Yoga Sūtras of Patañjali (North Point Press, 2009).
- Willem Kuyken et al., "Efficacy of Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Therapy in Prevention of Depressive Relapse", JAMA Psychiatry 73.6 (2016).